Review: these are the waterfalls in my head

these are the waterfalls in my head by JeFF Stumpo, winner of the 2026 Granite State Poetry Prize, is the author’s first full length poetry collection. His hallucinatory dream poems lead the reader into disorienting and troubled spaces, but they are all clearly aimed at both catharsis and human connection. To read this collection is to step under the waterfall with the writer, to become immersed and to get wet together. It’s an emotional and intellectual adventure, a sort of anti-hero’s journey, but one which leaves the reader with clearer eyes and wiser to the world.

The book seeks to frame the experience for us before we step into the waterfall, to guide and inform our experience. It begins with an academic epigraph documenting the negative nature of most children’s recurrent dreams, giving the impression that the unsettling nature of the work to come needs to be bolstered and explained. An introduction by Diannely Antigua, the judge of the 2026 Granite State Poetry Prize, offers the reader guidance in interpreting the writer’s craft and process and in understanding the broader social context of this project, which contains material not only from the poet’s traumatic experiences of recurrent nightmares, but also the experiences of others whom he interviewed.

The book’s table of contents is an exercise in anaphora, every poem starts with the word “Tonight,” creating a drumbeat of emphasis on the recurrence of the poet’s dilemma, stuck in a troubling present. The opening poem is a through-the-looking-glass style poem, in which an actively threatening self and a frightening world are attempting to enter the speaker’s world by coming through the bathroom mirror and grabbing the hands he is attempting to clean. This world is the foil to the speaker’s intentions; in it are “blood flowers blooming dustily.” The poem has a bright flash of paranoia, “It wants out,” imagining the frightening reflection as having its own malicious intentions. However, the speaker is grounded in self-awareness and realism about the source of the fear. There is no monster about to emerge, rather “you’ve always known you were the most frightening thing in your life.”

Between each “Tonight” poem is a graphic representation of the titular waterfalls, giving the impression of the tide coming in continually, before anything on the shore can be accomplished. Initially the dreams described in the poems are fraught because the speaker not only feels doomed (“You’re not going to make it home. You’re as good as a skull on a wall”) but also feels complicit in the terrible violence he witnesses. The dream portrayed in “Tonight you are a beautiful woman” involves fire and intense suffering on the part of the woman at the hand of a stranger, and ends with uncertainty: “You might be a beautiful woman. You might be a hand.” At times, it is a dream about “real” life which seems like a nightmare. “Tonight you are late at the office” has the lonely ambiance of an Edward Hopper painting and the surreal logic of an episode of “Severance.” Has the poet “missed the twins’ birthday”? Does the poet have twins? Are the numbers he types so industriously “imaginary”? Is he, and his vision of himself as a typical man doing typical work imaginary, he wonders, observing his own “fading hands”?

In the book’s final “Notes and appreciation” section, the poet describes the process of writing and assembling these poems based on nightmares not so much as a process of growth and increasing hope, but as a process of increasing openness and understanding as he listened to and wrote about the equally terrifying experiences of other dreamers. These connections come through in narrative dream poems in the latter half of the book such as “Tonight you find the devil in the bottom of a glass” in which the devil is a charmer and a con man, ready to listen to all kinds of stories of frustration without judgment (“That ex who ran off with the trucker”) but also willing to allow people to delude themselves in order to keep them in his grasp (“the devil don’t pick sides, that he don’t tell you to do nothing you don’t want anyway, that his voice just goes down smooth”). Mythical narratives like this one allow for the struggles of all readers to enter in as archetypal dilemmas.

The book’s closing poem “Tonight you are in the right body” provides an open door, the potential to explore unknown territory and to have a new experience outside the punishing cycle of nightmares. What this new experience will feel like is left uncertain, and because it’s unfamiliar and a break with longstanding patterns, it is a little unsettling. The poem doesn’t fulfill our wish for relief and happy anticipation. The antagonists of the speakers’ nightmares are gone in this vision, but feeling free of fear is the opposite of feeling excited, due to the novel lack of tension “defined by absence – no judge and no jury.” The poet’s pivot point comes later in his life than he would have wished, but he is finally able to choose a non-reactive response to fear: “[t]here is a stone rolling down a hill, and you are walking the other way.” “Forever” is no longer the speaker’s name or identity, and the reader walks away with the speaker to find this new life together, and to find words to describe a reframed reality.


Image: Cover of these are the waterfalls in my head by JeFF Stumpo (Yas Press, 2026), licensed under Fair Use Laws.

Heather Nelson
Latest posts by Heather Nelson (see all)

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.